Federal Court finds payments by an Electricity Distributor to customers do not give rise to decreasing adjustments

In AusNet Services Limited v Commissioner of Taxation [2026] FCA 1609 the Federal Court found that the applicant (AES), an electricity distributor that supplied connection services and supply services to customers and was required to make Guaranteed Service Level payments (GSL Payments) to customers if it failed to meet Guaranteed Service Levels, was not entitled to a decreasing adjustment with respect to the GSL Payments. The Court found that an adjustment event did not arise under Division 19 of the GST Act as the GSL Payments did not have the effect of changing the consideration payable by customers to AES for the provision of those services.

AES held a licence to distribute or supply electricity to customers (the Distribution Licence). The Distribution Licence was the primary source of obligations for AES in relation to its licence to distribute or supply electricity.

AES did not bill end-users directly for the provision and use of AES’s services related to the supply of electricity and basic connection fee-based services. Similarly, customers did not make payments to AES directly for the provision and use of these services. Rather, the flow of funds for these services was managed by the electricity retailer. The customers therefore received a single electricity bill which incorporated charges for various components across the supply chain.

If AES did not meet certain service standards as a distributor, it is required to make GSL Payments to affected customers. The categories of payments included: payments associated with not connecting by an agreed date; payments for late appointments; and payments associated with supply issues (outages/interruptions). The quantum of the relevant GSL Payment turned upon the terms and threshold of the service standard not met by AES. The GSL Payment was to be reflected as a credit to the payment (or refund) owing on the relevant customer’s bill. This credit was included in the charges sent by AES to the retailer to be passed on to that customer by the retailer.

AES’ primary contention was that the services were provided by AES to the retailer and the retailer supplied those services to the customer (the Indirect Supply Analysis) and that the GSL Payments were an adjustment under Division 134 of the GST Act. In the alternative, AES contended that the services were provided by AES directly to customers (the Direct Supply Analysis) and that the GSL Payments were an adjustment under Division 19. The Commissioner contended that the Direct Supply Analysis applied and that the GSL Payments did not give rise to an adjustment under Division 19.

The Court concluded that the Direct Supply Analysis applied and that the making of the GSL Payments did not constitute an “adjustment event” within the meaning of s 19-10. In particular, the Court found that the making of GSL Payments did not constitute an event which had the effect of changing the consideration for the supply of the services by AES to the customer. Accordingly, the making of the GSL Payments did not give rise to decreasing adjustments under Div 19.

In finding that the Direct Supply Analysis applied, the Court observed that the contractual and other like documents that formed part of the regulatory regime did not point consistently in one direction. However, while there may be ambiguity in the contractual and other like documents, from a practical perspective, the services were provided by AES directly to the customers (with billing and payment being done through the retailer). The physical tasks involved in providing the Connection Services and the Supply Services were carried out by AES (through employees or contractors); they were not carried out by the retailer. Further, from a commercial perspective, the Court considered that the services were provided by AES directly to the customers (with billing and payment being done through the retailer).

With respect to Division 19, AES contended that the GSL Payments had the effect of changing the consideration for the supply of the services by AES to the customer. In considering this issue, the Court observed that there was no issue that AES supplied the services (the connection and supply services) to customers and that the services were supplied to customers for consideration. The question was whether there was a change to this consideration due to the making of the GSL Payments – did the making of those payments have the effect of changing the consideration for the supply of the services within the meaning of s 19-10(1)?

In considering this issue, the Court (at [177]) observed that “is not enough that, as a result of the GSL Payments, there is a reduction in the overall amount paid or payable by the customer. The question is a more specific one: whether there is a reduction in the consideration for the supply of the Relevant Services. Putting this another way, are the GSL Payments an integer in the consideration for the supply of the Relevant Services?”

The Court (at [174]) observed that it was necessary to have regard to the nature of the GST and the lens through which the issue (and the matter more generally) is to be approached, referring to the statement of Thawley J in Landcom v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [2022] FCA 510 at [206] that “It may be accepted as the Commissioner submitted that, for the purposes of s 9-5, a practical common-sense approach should be taken to the question of whether there is a single supply and to the characterisation of that supply, having regard to relevant contractual terms and commercial reality…The recognition that the GST is a practical business tax, which informs that approach in relation to the characterisation of the relevant supply for the purposes of the “basic rules”, also informs the construction of Div 75, contained in the “special rules”.”

In finding that the GSL Payments did not have the effect of changing the consideration for the services, the Court relied on the following matters:

  • under the regulatory regime , the GSL Payments were not constructed as, or referred to as, payments which effected a change in (a reduction to) the consideration payable by the customer for the supply of the Relevant Services.
  • the purposes of the GSL Payments scheme do not provide any positive support for the proposition that the making of the GSL Payments had the effect of changing the consideration for the supply of the Relevant Services.
  • there was no correlation between the amount of a GSL Payment and the amount otherwise payable by the customer for the supply of the Connection Services or the Supply Services.
  • it was possible for the GSL Payments to exceed the amount otherwise payable by the customer as consideration for the supply of the Connections Services. The fact that a GSL Payment could exceed the amount otherwise payable for the supply of the Connection Services suggests that, as a practical matter, the GSL Payments are not in the nature of a change in the consideration for the supply of the services; they are independent of that amount.
  • It is true that the GSL Payments were related to the Relevant Services, as they were payable in circumstances where the distributor failed to meet certain minimum standards for the performance of the Relevant Services. However, it does not necessarily follow that the making of the GSL Payments had the effect of changing the consideration for the supply of the Relevant Services.

Ultimately, the Court concluded (at [186]) that the the better view was that the GSL Payments were standalone amounts which AES was required to pay to the customer and were not amounts which had the effect of changing the consideration paid or payable by the customer to AES for the supply of the Connection Services or the Supply Services. Putting this another way, the GSL Payments were not an integer in the consideration for the supply of the Connection Services or the Supply Services.

Leave a Reply